Showing posts with label communication. Show all posts
Showing posts with label communication. Show all posts

Sunday, May 11, 2025

Men Are From Mars Women Are From Venus

Please excuse the tired metaphor, but I really think that John Gray was onto something. This isn't about his book, and I by no means align my marital perspectives with all of his (both as a married person and as a marriage counselor). However, I do agree that men and women are two completely different creatures.

There have been many books written regarding the psychological differences between males and females. Although I think most people recognize that men and women are very different, in some ways we sometimes think that the other gender is just a different version of us. But women are not just prettier, more emotional men, and men are not egotistical stoic women.

You can read R' Aharon Feldman's The River, The Kettle and The Bird  to learn about "understanding the different natures of male and female, controlling anger and criticism, fostering love, giving and gratitude." John Gray's Men Are From Mars, Women Are From Venus books share "a practical and proven way for men and women to improve their communication by acknowledging the differences between their needs, desires, and behaviors"

Alison Armstrong, author of In Sync With the Opposite Sex, Making Sense of Men, Understanding Women and other such books/workshops writes about how each gender has different realities. Because this is true, and many people don't understand this, we treat the opposite gender based on specific expectations and thus in a way that causes them to treat us poorly. Clearly, this gets in the way of having a mutually satisfying relationship.

For example, Armstrong relates that most men are driven by duty, honor, and obligation. Many women don't understand what this means and assume that men make decisions based on the same things that women do, to avoid someone being mad at them for example, or some other emotional reason. She explains that men (generally) want to take care of, make happy, spend time with, contribute to, and protect their women. A man responds to how he's treated, so if a woman stops being receptive or criticizes him, he loses motivation to be her knight. Armstrong proposes that a woman can "turn her prince into a frog" if she treats him in the way she naturally treats the females in her life.

Gray talks about how men and women tally giving and receiving love differently (women want consistent small things not just one big act of caring), how they deal with stress differently (women want to talk about things but when men are stressed they retreat and isolate), among other ideas.

There are so many books out there at this point that will share the secrets to a happy coexistence. I think it boils down to a simple understanding -- men and women are by definition different beings.

So let's break it down. While it is true that not all men are the same or want the same things, and not all women are the same and want the same things, there are some very basic differences that show up across cultures and upbringings. I've seen it where the guy sometimes will have the more stereotypical female traits and vice versa, but generally partners end up with someone who sees and experiences the world very differently than themselves. 

People generally marry someone who is their foil in so many ways. Whether its this psychoanalytically understood "attachment reenactment" where someone (often subconsciously) marries their partner to recreate and resolve old childhood wounds, or just simply that opposites attract, it would be boring to marry someone exactly like you. Because this is true, you have to realize that you'll likely end up with someone who doesn't speak the same "language" as you. 

The more we understand the opposite sex, the better we can get along with and support them.

Male and female realities are often very different:
  • They give and receive love differently.
    • Most stereotypical men lean towards showing love via physical touch, acts of service, and problem solving
    • Women show love through words of affirmation, quality time and emotional nurturing.
  • They process emotions differently.
    • Men are generally socialized to suppress emotions and/or manage them privately
    • Women express and process emotions more openly and seek connection and verbal processing to feel better
  • They communicate differently. 
    • Men tend to be more solution-focused
    • Women are process-focused, and they can walk through emotions without needing a solution, just empathy and presence
  • The conflict/connection dance is different between genders. 
    • Men generally shut down and withdraw in the face of conflict
    • Women often push for further connection and conversation
  • Their validation needs differ. 
    • Men feel loved when they're respected, appreciated, and admired for what they do
    • Women tend to feel loved when they are seen, heard, and understood for what they are
Of course, these are all stereotypes, and you may find men and women that take on the more stereotypical male or female opposite tendencies. These patterns are influenced too by culture, upbringing, and personality, not just sex/gender. 

The important piece to remember though, is that no matter what side of the fence you find yourself on, you're not looking across the table at someone of the opposite gender that in general thinks like you. He or she is seeing the world through a different kaleidoscope if you will, a different set of rules, different needs, a different coding language. Act accordingly -- ask questions, don't make assumptions, be curious, learn what s/he needs or wants. 

Monday, December 24, 2018

Love at First Fight

People don't talk about the challenges of marriage. From the disagreements (that are present in every relationship!), to the learning a new dance and balancing new responsibilities. All my friends who got married years before me just said, "Marriage is so great!" Now that I'm married (and trying to eradicate the stigma of imperfection as much as I can) and I'm talking about the challenges I see, the same friends are saying things like "Yeah, the first while I was married I thought I'd made a mistake and married the wrong person."

Life isn't easy. It's hard work. But anything worthwhile is going to be difficult. No matter how well you know your spouse before you get married (and usually it isn't very well in frum circles), the game changes when you live with someone, when this person becomes your family.

It's normal to fight. I've heard stories about couples who thought their marriage was headed for divorce when they had their first fight. Disagreements are part of this beautiful mess; it's in the very fabric of relationships. Really if there is no disagreeing there is apathy, and apathy is the opposite of love and passion. No matter how similar two people may be (and most of the time spouses aren't that similar, they "work" as a couple because they compliment each other), they will not agree all the time. Perhaps it's not even about agreeing about something, but one person does something the other person takes offense at. There's a big learning curve.

As you live together you learn each others' sore spots and ways of being (for a lack of better terminology). When he raises his voice it might not mean he's upset, maybe he's just excited. It's easy to take so many things personally, but most of the time it's really not about you. He might be upset and withdraw, but often it's not about her. It's likely something outside the marriage that is bothering him. When she takes it personally, and he doesn't have the presence of mind to let her know he's not upset at her but upset at something else, it creeps into the marriage and can drive a wedge.

Communication is key. Always.

It's not always easy to talk about things though, but it's always a good practice to not let things fester however hard it is to talk about.